The Cold War was essentially a battle
of ideologies between the Communist East and the Capitalist West. The Vietnam
War (between 1955 and 1975) had an important impact on the development of this
war. According to historian Steve Phillips, “To the American Government the
[Vietnam] War was less about Vietnamese independence than it was a conflict
between communism and the capitalist free world.” In this way The Vietnam War
furthered the course of The Cold War, and greatly influenced the public opinion
of American citizens, as well as the image of America worldwide.
From the
late 1850s until the outbreak of the Second World War, Vietnam was under French
colonial control. During World War II Vietnam was occupied by Japan. “The
French, however, wished to reassert control over the region” (Phillips), but
according to historians Keely Rogers and Jo Thomas, “most Vietnamese had no
desire to let Vietnam return to the rule of the French after 1945”, and thus a
struggle for power ensued. Due to long term domination by their oppressors,
there was a popular rise of nationalism, led by the communist Ho Chi Minh. Minh
was one of the main defenders of Vietnam during the Second World War, and
leader of the Vietminh communist/nationalist party. However, fearing a
communist takeover of Vietnam and the threat of the “domino effect” (a theory
which stated that once one country would fall to communism, all of its
neighbours would too) America, under president Harry Truman began to send
military aid. According to Rogers and Thomas, “In March 1950, military aid was
sent to help France defeat the Vietminh. This aid was continued by Eisenhower”.
By 1954 United States was funding 80% of the war. However, the civil war
was, according to Phillips, “a crushing defeat for France”. During the final
Vietnamese offensive alone “16,000 [French] troops were either killed during
action or captured afterwards. French rule could no longer be sustained”
(Phillips). Thus, in 1954 the Geneva Accords were signed, agreeing on various
topics. Vietnam would become independent, there would be a temporary
division of Vietnam on the 17 parallel, with Ho Chi Minh controlling the north
of the country, and Bao Dai (the former emperor who had collaborated with the
French) would rule the south. There were to be free elections to unite the
country in 1956. However, America disapproved of this agreement and did not
sign the Geneva Accords as they did not agree with the placing of a communist
as leader of North Vietnam.
In
retaliation, America created SEATO (the South East Asian Treaty Organisation),
signed by Australia, Britain, France, New Zealand, Pakistan, the Philippines
and Thailand. These countries agreed that in the case of an attack on one of
them, (if they anonymously agreed) they would take military action. Meanwhile,
America was sending increasing amounts of military advisors. According to
Rogers and Thomas, “there were 17,000 ‘advisers’ in Vietnam by the time of
Kennedy’s death [in 1963]”.. According to Rogers and Thomas, “None of these
measures succeeded in limiting the growing success of the Vietcong attacks on
the South. Indeed, measures such as the Strategic Hamlets Program and the
spraying of Agent Orange only alienated the local peasant population further.”
The emperor of Southern Vietnam, Bao Dai, according to Phillips “preferred to
live the life of an international playboy and was removed in 1955. Real power
now presided in Ngo Dinh Diem… he was a dictator and his government was riddled
with corruption”. Features of his regime included the repression of religion,
lack of reform, which created growth of opposition.
After the
Gulf of Tonkin Incident of 1964¸ where an American Destroyer was shot at by
North Vietnamese patrol boats, America became militarily involved in the war.
Due to the SEATO alliance, soon Australia, New Zealand, the Philippines and
Thailand were also supplying troops. They employed policies of search and
destroy missions to eliminate Vietcong (a communist guerrilla organisation
operating in South Vietnam) members, spraying of harmful chemicals such as the
infamous Agent Orange on jungle and the Strategic Hamlets program, by which
peasants were resettled into fortified villages to avoid potential
communist sympathies. These did little to help the situation. They also
introduced a new strategy called Operation Rolling Thunder, which involved “the
selection of strategic targets in North Vietnam to be bombed in order to put
pressure on the North to stop supplying the Vietcong, end the war and start
negotiations” (Phillips). However, this operation was a massive failure;
“The USSR and China were quick to offer replacements for supplies damaged…
during Rolling Thunder, supplies to the Vietcong by the North actually
increased” (Phillips). Despite this failure, or perhaps because of it,
America was dramatically increasing its number of soldiers. According to
Phillips, “Within 9 weeks [of the Gulf of Tonkin Incident] 99,000 US soldiers
were in South Vietnam… the number of troops increased rapidly, reaching 385,000
in 1966 and 535,000 in 1968.”
By 1968,
the war was looking grim for America. After the Vietcong launched the Tet
Offensive against the South, “the consequences of the offensive were to lead
the USE to re-evaluate its commitment to Vietnam” (Phillips). The Tet
Offensive was an initiative by the Vietcong carried out in February 1968, which
was meant to coincide with Tet, the Vietnamese New Year. The offensive
consisted of simultaneous surprise attacks on 35 towns and cities in the South,
using 80,000 troops. According to Phillips, “with over half their soldiers
killed, the Tet Offensive was a severe military defeat for the communists. Yet,
its wider impact was to swing the situation heavily in their favour.” Phillips
also states that, “events within the USA were, at the time, pushing the
government to consider whether the human and financial costs of the war were
worth the gain, especially as victory over the communists was beginning to look
unobtainable.” Both sides were desperate for the war to end. In 1968, Richard
Nixon became the new president of America. His solution to the Vietnam problem
was ‘Vietnamisation’, or “training and supplying arms to the government of
South Vietnam so that US troops could be withdrawn” (Phillips). However, this
policy, according to Phillips, “showed that Nixon, like his predecessors, had
failed to understand the nature of the war… South Vietnam had become, more than
ever, an army without a country.” There were 415,000 American troops in Vietnam
in 1970, and this number dropped to 239,000 in 1971 and only 47,000 in 1972.
The troops that remained had low morale. “Desertions became commonplace,
increasing by 400 per cent between 1969 and 1971. More concerned with their own
survival, soldiers sometimes killed their officers rather than obey orders to
fight... in 1971 15% of US troops in Vietnam were addicted to hard drugs and
four times as many soldiers were being treated for drug-related problems as
they were for combat wounds” (Phillips).
In 1972
the communist launched what is now called the Easter Offensive. “This offensive
contained large numbers of North Vietnamese forces supplied with Soviet
weaponry” (Phillips). It ended in a stalemate; “the realisation that
there would be no quick end to the war led both sides to engage in peace talks
while continuing to fight” (Philllips). American hopes for an all-out military
success had faded, however, according to Phillips, the government believed that
“if they could not win the war, they could still inflict enough damage on North
Vietnam to bring to the negotiating table in the future.” During the Paris
Peace Talks of 1972, this situation was reached. Henry Kissinger, the American
National Security Advisor, and Le Duc Tho, the leader of the North Vietnamese
delegation had agreed on a ceasefire. This ceasefire was agreed to on the terms
that the forces of North and South Vietnam would retain the areas which they
currently controlled. This was advantageous to North Vietnam as they controlled
large areas of the South. The other condition of the ceasefire was that all foreign
troops had to be withdrawn from Indochina (South-East Asia). However, the South
Vietnamese government under the new leader President Thieu, who was not
included in negotiations, refused to accept this settlement. According to
Phillips, “he viewed it as an abandonment of his regime to the forces of
communism”. According to Rogers and Thomas, “After a decade of military
involvement, the loss of hundreds of thousands of American lives, billions of
dollars and the damaging division of U.S. public opinion, the Americans pulled
out of Vietnam in 1973.” Now that most US troops had been withdrawn, “North
Vietnam was determined to unite the country and South Vietnam, not deprived of
nearly all US military help was too demoralised to offer much resistance” (Phillips)
The newly made ceasefire “only delayed the final outcome of the war”
(Phillips). In March 1975 the communists launched a Spring Offensive against
the South. According to Phillips, “the South Vietnamese army fled in panic”.
President Thieu resigned, and fled abroad while the presidential palace was
invaded by the North using Soviet tanks. Phillips states that “the speed of
South Vietnam’s collapse took the North by surprise but without US support the
regime in the South, lacking any popular support of its own, had crumbled”. In
this way, the Vietnam War ended.
“In the
context of the Cold War, the Vietnam War was a victory for communist and a
failure for US policy” (Phillips). The was originally intended to protect
South-East Asia against communism, however upon its conclusion Vietnam became
unified under communism, and later in 1975, Laos and Cambodia also became
communist, bringing US fears of the Domino Effect to life. Vietnam also created
major budget troubles for America. Between 1965 and 1975 the United States
spent $111 billion on the war. Popular dissatisfaction demonstrated by public
protests and epitomized by the heartless massacre of women and children in
village of My Lai by American troops in 1968, which caused “widespread
revulsion in the USA… the My Lai massacre was only one example of the
atrocities committed by both sides during the war” (Phillips). The
dissatisfaction of American people and huge budget deficits created by the
Vietnam War were major causes of détente (relaxation of tensions) between the
USSR and America between 1971 and 1979. According to Phillips, “The Vietnam War
had started as a war of independence that turned into a war over the future
direction of the country by the intervention of outside forces operating within
the context of the Cold War.”